it still says bum on the passport
Thursday, 26 July 2012–
classifications,
publishing,
writing
So at the end of July I get to be a published novelist -- if
you want to stretch the definition and include Westerns in the classification
of novel.
What do you mean “It’s a book, so of course you’re a
novelist”?
Ah, sweet, naive you. Sweet naive me, too. But I’ve learned
it doesn’t really work that way.
While no one can ever take away the fact that I’ll have
written and published a book with a respected publisher, the type of book I’ll
have published will certainly weight people’s prejudices.
“A Western? What, cowboys and stuff?”
“Uhm. Yes.”
“Oh dear.”
Some writers will tell you that they’ve enormous admiration
and respect for anyone who can trot out the required number of words and make
them something like cohesive, throwing in characterisation and plot and maybe
even some nice prose every now and again. While others...
Hmm. Putting it politely, as they rarely do: You do it
properly and aim for high art or you’re a hack.
There’s long been a clash between mainstream and genre
publishing. It’s best summed up with that old nugget regarding the definitions
of what’s science fiction and what’s literature. “If it’s science fiction it
can’t be good, and if it’s good it can’t be science fiction.” Thus SF pieces
like 1984 and The Handmaid’s Tale are secreted out of genre and
given a spit and polish and promoted as mainstream literature. While some fine
SF novels, Dune or The Fountains of Paradise say, are happily
left in the ghetto.
There’s not even the single ghetto, either. There are plenty
of them. Crime’s a ghetto. Fantasy. Romance. Chick Lit. Sad Git Lit (as I call
the writers producing the male equivalent of Chick Lit). Even historical
fiction. And you can bet your bottom dollar and all the phlegm in the spittoon
that the Western is a ghetto area too. Mainstream is the exalted place, standing
high and remote above all others. To some writers at least. Even if mainstream
fiction takes so much from genre, sadly to its detriment without its writers
even knowing it.
Me, I guess I’ll just keep bumming around. But just in case
it offends anyone, I won’t be putting “Writer” down on the passport any time
soon.